State & Local Analysis
Montana Court Awards AECOM Partial Fees
March 24, 2026
A Montana court has issued a partial victory for contractor AECOM in a legal dispute over extra work performed during a 2019 plant turnaround at Exxon's Montana refinery. The jury awarded AECOM a net recovery of $44 million from a $100 million claim, with the court granting $5.2 million in attorneys' fees reflecting 43% of the requested amount based on partial success. However, the court denied recovery of expert and e-discovery costs under Montana law, emphasizing that trial courts are not required to perform exhaustive fee accounting.
- Why this matters: This ruling clarifies the application of Montana's Prompt Payment Act and lien statutes in contractor disputes, highlighting partial fee awards and cost recovery limitations.
- Contractors and legal counsel should consider the implications for fee recovery strategies in state-level construction and extra work claims.
- Procurement professionals managing contracts in Montana should be aware of potential legal cost exposures and the partial nature of fee awards in dispute resolutions.
- This case underscores the importance of detailed contract documentation and legal preparedness for extra work claims in refinery and industrial facility projects.
The court awarded AECOM 43% of its attorneys27 fees or $5.2 million reflecting partial success.
— Court ruling
Trial courts need not26#8230; become green-eyeshade accountants.
— U.S. Supreme Court (cited by court)
Agencies
Montana Prompt Payment Act, Montana lien statute
Vendors
AECOM, Exxon
Contracts
$100 million claimed by AECOM; $64 million jury verdict; $44 million net recovery