# HHS OCR Settles HIPAA Cases in Pennsylvania, California

HHS’s Office for Civil Rights announced its 55th and 56th HIPAA Right of Access enforcement resolutions, involving providers in Pennsylvania and California. Shen Smiles agreed to pay a $140,000 civil money penalty, while Azul Vision agreed to a $50,000 settlement and a two-year corrective action plan. These cases signal ongoing enforcement around individuals’ timely access to medical records, which is relevant to healthcare agencies and contractors handling health-data operations, even though the announcements describe enforcement actions rather than procurement opportunities.

- Healthcare providers and contractors supporting health-data operations should review access-request workflows, PHI safeguards, recordkeeping, workforce training, and compliance monitoring.
- Procurement teams can use these enforcement outcomes when assessing how contract scopes and vendor oversight address timely records access and protection of health information.

**Jurisdictions:** federal
**Industries:** Healthcare
**Topics:** Regulatory Compliance
**Published:** November 18, 2026

### Government Entities
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights (HHS OCR)

### Sources
- [HHS OCR Announces 55th and 56th Settlements in Pennsylvania and California related to HIPAA Right of Enforcement Actions With Respect to Individuals’ Timely Access to Medical Records | Saul Ewing LLP - JDSupra](https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/hhs-ocr-announces-55th-and-56th-2820016) - JD Supra