Local Historic District Commission Aug 24, 2026

The Town of Amherst Local Historic District Commission held a meeting on August 24, 2026, primarily to review two applications for accessory dwelling units (ADUs) at 290 and 321 Lincoln Avenue. The commission discussed the design, scale, and placement of the proposed ADUs, with significant public and commissioner concern about the size, architectural appropriateness, and impact on the historic district character. The 290 Lincoln Avenue ADU, featuring a three-car garage with living space above, was criticized for being out of scale, having an inappropriate roof style, and being too close to the street. Commissioners noted that while the ADU is a protected use and cannot be denied outright, the commission can influence design elements. The applicant was encouraged to revise the design to reduce massing and better fit the historic context. The 321 Lincoln Avenue ADU was viewed as less problematic but still required design adjustments, particularly regarding attic habitable space, which state law likely prohibits. Both projects were continued to a future meeting with a site visit scheduled to better assess their impact. No contract awards or procurement decisions were made during this meeting.