City of Fairhope Board of Adjustments June 16, 2025

The City of Fairhope Board of Adjustments held a public hearing on June 16, 2025, to consider a variance request by property owners Robert and Melanie Roberts for a 20.7-foot front setback and a 3.14-foot side setback variance on a property zoned R2 at 657 North Mobile Street. The discussion focused extensively on the unique lot conditions, historical platting issues, and the fact that many neighboring properties also do not conform to current setback requirements. The Roberts argued that the house was built in line with other houses on the block and that the city's zoning ordinance was inconsistently applied, while city staff and opposing parties emphasized the importance of adhering to setback rules to protect public good, green space, and property values. After hearing from multiple parties, including legal representatives and neighbors, the Board voted unanimously to deny both the front and side setback variance requests. No new contracts, procurement decisions, or budget allocations were discussed during the meeting.