Flagstaff Heritage Preservation Commission Meeting - May 20, 2026

The City of Flagstaff Heritage Preservation Commission held a meeting on May 20, 2026, focusing primarily on historic preservation grant applications and the review of a significant redevelopment project at 19 West Birch Avenue. The commission approved a level one historic signs and facades grant of up to $10,000 for 910 North Leroux Street to replace deteriorating trim boards and repaint the exterior. A detailed discussion ensued regarding the phase two cultural resource study for 19 West Birch Avenue, with the commission ultimately rejecting the study pending revisions to include more detailed architectural drawings, correct addresses, and enhanced material depictions. The commission also reviewed the certificate of appropriateness for the demolition of the existing building and the design of a new hotel and parking garage on the site. They voted to require a certificate of economic hardship for the demolition, emphasizing the need for further review and mitigation. The commission requested additional design information, including renderings showing the new buildings' mass and scale in context with surrounding historic structures, and greater incorporation of Malpais stone on the exterior to better reflect Flagstaff's historic character. Public comments highlighted concerns about preserving local history and the impact of new construction on downtown's historic feel. The meeting concluded with updates on other preservation projects and a discussion about the city's new general plan and its implications for historic preservation.